Course title:  Applied General Equilibrium Trade Policy Analysis

 

 

Dr. Zhi WANG

Researcher

US International Trade Commission

 

Objective This short course intends to provide basic concepts and necessary tools for senior and graduate students in applied economics, international trade, and international relations to construct Computable General Equilibrium model to conduct trade policy analysis. The emphasis of this course is on the word applied. Students will work with explicit function forms, numerical examples, and computer software (GAMS) to learn the basic skills of how to develop their own models based on particular policy issues at hand, including developing an appropriate model structure, assembling and balancing the benchmark data set, deriving and calibrating the model, computing counterfactual equilibriums, and interpreting results.

 

Prerequirements It is assumed that the student has taken principles of microeconomics, Calculus, Liner Algebra, and basic computer programming.

 

Course Description

The course will start from introducing the basic structure of a CGE model and its role in trade policy analysis; then the building block and basic structure of a single country and a multi-country CGE model will be presented in both their semantic and mathematical representations.

 

The Social Accounting Matrix provides a consistent framework to organize statistical data for an economy to satisfy the requirements of a benchmark data set for CGE modeling. Because this accounting system is central to any general equilibrium policy analysis, the Social Accounting Matrix and the method of how to balance it are also covered after outline basic structure of CGE model.

 

Conducting general equilibrium trade policy analysis one has to know general equilibrium theory, to be familiar with data and be able to manipulate and convert it into a model admissible form, to have a clean sense of policy issues and institutional structure, and to be able to implement the model in computer, i.e. the knowledge of computer programming is one of the basic requirements of CGE analysis. Therefore, an introduction to the computer software, General Algebraic Modeling System (GAMS), which is one of the major modeling language widely used today in CGE modeling will also integrate into the course. Students go through this course should be able to conduct simple programming task (or at least be able to understand GAMS program).

 

After developing the necessary concept framework and empirical tools, Two applications related to Taiwan will be presented as empirical example of general equilibrium trade policy analysis. Students will have a chance to see how the conterfactual experiment results are interpreted. There will also be several readings of survey of the literature on the use of CGE analysis in the policy-making process.  

 

Course Requirements:

 

There will be daily reading assignment designed to reinforce the material covered in class lectures. As the course progresses the use of micro-computer will be involved.  

 

Course Outline:

Six lectures

I. Introduction of Computable General Equilibrium models and why we need Computable General Equilibrium Trade Policy Analysis?

Readings:

 

Francois Joseph F. and Kenneth A. Reinert (1997) Applied Methods for Trade Policy Analysis – A handbook Cambridge University Press, United Kingdom. Part 1.

 

Shoven J. B. and J. Whalley (1992) "Applying general equilibrium." Chapter 1

 

Shoven, J. B. and J. Whalley (1984) "Applied General Equilibrium Models of Taxation and

International Trade," Journal of Economic Literature Vol. 22, pp 1007-1051.

 

de Melo, J. " Computable General Equilibrium Models for Trade Policy Analysis in Developing Countries," Journal of Policy Modeling, 10(3):469-503

 

Mercenier, J. and T. N. Srinivasan (1994) "Applied General Equilibrium and Economic Development." The University of Michigan Press. Chapters 1 and 2

 

Ginsburgh, Victor and Michiel Keyzer (1997) The Structure of Applied General

Equilibrium Models, The MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts. Chapter 1 and 2.

 

Class note 1 Introduction

Class 1 Power Point 

 

II. Basic Structure for CGE Models

1. The role of neoclassical theories of producer and consumer behavior, competitive equilibrium in structuring the model   

2. Notation and building Block

3.  Basic structure of single country CGE models

4.  Basic structure of multi-country CGE models

5  Macro closure in CGE models.

6. Dynamics in CGE model

Readings:

 

Dervis, K. J. de Melo and S. Robinson (1982) "General equilibrium models for development policy." Gambridge University Press. Chapter 5-7.

 

Shoven J. B. and J. Whalley (1992) "Applying general equilibrium." Chapter 2 and 4

 

Wang, Zhi and Fan Zhai "Tariff Reduction, Tax Replacement, and Its Implication for Income Distribution in China." Journal of Comparative Economics, 26(2): 358-387, June 1998.

 

Robinson, Sherman, Zhi Wang and Will Martin “Capturing the Implications of Services Trade Liberalization.” Economic System Research, 14(1):3-33, March 2002.

 

The G-cubed (Agriculture) Model: A tool for Analyzing Agriculture in a Globalizing World.” (with Warwick McKibbin), Brookings Discussion Paper in International Economics, No. 139, Brookings Institution, Washington D.C., June 1998.

 

Lofgren, Hans, Rebecca Lee Harris, Sherman Robinson “A Standard Computable General Equilibrium (CGE) Model in GAMS” page 8 -17.

 

Ginsburgh, Victor and Michiel Keyzer (1997) The Structure of Applied General Equilibrium Models, The MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts. Chapter 3.

 

Class note2 Model Specification

Class note 2b

Class 2 Power Point

 

III. Data Structure: An Accounting Framework and Benchmark Data Set for CGE Analysis: The Social Accounting Matrix (SAM)

1. Basic concept and framework of a Social Accounting Matrix (SAM)

2. SAM underlying CGE models

3. Parameter Specification and Model Calibration

Reading:

 

Pyatt, G (1988) "A SAM Approach to Modeling." Journal of Policy Modeling 10(3):327-352.

 

Lofgren, Hans, Rebecca Lee Harris, Sherman Robinson “A Standard Computable General Equilibrium (CGE) Model in GAMS” page 3 -7. 

 

Robinson, Sherman, Andrea Cattaneo and Moataz El-Said. 2001. “Updating and estimating a Social Accounting Matrix using cross entropy methods.” Economic Systems Research, Vol. 13, No.1, pp. 47-64.

 

McDonald, Scott and Karen Thierfelder (2004), Deriving a Global Social Accounting Matrix from GTAP Versions 5 and 6 Data, GTAP Technical Paper No. 22. Purdue University.  https://www.gtap.agecon.purdue.edu/resources/tech_papers.asp

 

Class note 3

Class 3 Power Point

 

GAMS Lab and Discussion 1

Introduction to GAMS, Using GAMSIDE, Basic GAMS Programming, balancing and updating SAM as a Constrained Matrix Problem.  

Reading:

 

McCarl, Bruce A. “ Using GAMSIED

Rosenthal, RiChard E. “A GAMS Totorial” http://www.gams.com/docs/gams/Tutorial.pdf

Brook, A. D. Kendrick, A. Meeraus and R. Raman (1998) "GAMS - A User's Guide."

GAMS Development Corporation. Washington, D.C.

 http://www.gams.com/docs/gams/GAMSUsersGuide.pdf

Sherman Robinson, Andrea Cattaneo, Moataz El-Said, "Estimating a Social Accounting Matrix Using Cross Entropy Methods," International Food Policy Research Institute, October 1998.
GAMS Program and Data Part 1.

 

Class Lab 1

Lab 1 note

 

IV. Constraint Matrix balance procedure and its applications in data reconciliations

Readings:

 

Patrick Canning and Zhi WangA Flexible Mathematical Programming Model to Estimate Interregional Input-Output Accounts.” Journal of Regional Sciences 45(3):539-563, August 2005.

 

Class Note 4

 

 

V. Application of Recursive Dynamic CGE Model in Trade Policy Analysis: The Economic Impact of China and Taiwan Entering the World Trade Organization

 Reading:

 

Wang, Zhi “WTO Accession, ‘Greater China’ Free Trade Area and Economic Integration across the Taiwan Strait”, China Economic Review, 14(3): 316-349, October 2003. Popular version in China Economic Analysis by Cross-Strait Interflow Prospect Foundation Working Paper, September, 2003. 

 

Wang, Zhi Impact of China’s WTO Accession on the Patterns of World Trade.” Journal of Policy Modeling 25(1): 1-41, January 2003.

 

Class 5 Power Point

 

VI. Application of Static CGE Model in Trade Policy Analysis: The Impact of Economic Integration of “Greater China”.

Reading:

 

Wang, Zhi and G. Edward Schuh, "The Impact of Economic Integration among Taiwan, Hong Kong and China: A Computable General Equilibrium Analysis."  Pacific Economic Review, 5(2):229-262, Special Issue on Hong Kong Reversion to China, May 2000.

 

Wang, Zhi and G. Edward Schuh “The Emergence of a ‘Greater China’ and its Impact on World Trade – A Computable General Equilibrium Analysis.” Journal of Comparative Economics 30(3): 531-566, September 2002.

 

Class 6 Power Point

 

GAMS Lab and Discussion 2

Calibration of the CGE Models in GAMS.  Simulations in GAMS CGE model.

IFPRI standard single country CGE model

CEA multi-country CGE model

Reading:

 

Lofgren, Hans, Rebecca Lee Harris, Sherman Robinson “A Standard Computable General Equilibrium (CGE) Model in GAMS” page 42-45.

 

Keyzer, Michiel (1997) “Building Applied General Equilibrium Models with GAMS: Examples and Additional Utility” Memo

GAMS Program and Data Part 2.

 

Lab 2 note

 

Temporary GAMS license file

 

Home